Welcome to blogs.ocweekly.com
Blogs
  • News
    • Daily News
    • News Articles
    • Moxley Confidential
    • National
    • Letters
  • Music
    • Top Picks
    • Heard Mentality
    • Entertainment Ads
    • Submit An Event
  • Calendar
    • Top Picks
    • Submit an Event
    • Valentine's Day Events
  • Restaurants
    • Restaurant Guide
    • Reviews
    • This Hole-In-the-Wall Life
    • Stick a Fork In It
    • Sponsored Online Menus
    • Restaurant Ads
  •  
  • Arts
    • Theater
    • Books
    • Trendzilla
    • Submit an Event
  • Films
    • Now Showing
    • Movie Showtimes
    • Reviews
    • Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Media Kit
  • Classifieds
    • Free Classifieds
    • Real Estate For Sale
    • Virtual Career Fair
    • Personals
    • Personals Blogs
    • Alternative Healing
  • Blogs
    • Navel Gazing
    • Heard Mentality
    • Stick A Fork In It
  • Columns
    • Ask A Mexican
    • Hey You!
    • Savage Love
    • Letters
  • Best Of
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bars & Clubs
    • Food & Drink
    • People & Places
    • Shopping & Services
    • Best of Ads
    • Readers Choice
  • Bars/Clubs
    • Bars/Clubs Home
    • Bars/Club Ads
    • Marijuana Dispensaries
  • Archives
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Events
    • Street Team
    • Join the Street Team
    • On Sale!
    • Free Stuff
    • Sponsored Concert Calendars
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • School Daze

    Buy a Fruit Cup, Save College Summer Session

    By Fiorella Casella

    1
  • Dishney

    Fat People at Disneyland: An Appreciation

    By Vickie Chang

    2
  • Breaking News

    Judge in Jailhouse Murder Failed to Disclose Conflict

    By Nick Schou

    3
  • A Clockwork Orange

    District Attorney Objects to Judge's Gang-Banger Sentences

    By Matt Coker

    4
  • A Clockwork Orange

    OC Impacts Some of the Country's Worst Freeway Commutes

    By Matt Coker

    5
  • Gunkist Memories

    Alba and Arellano Are Cousins; You Can See It in the Foreheads

    By Gustavo Arellano

    6
  • Wax On, Wax Off

    Art is Self-Taught Robb Havassy's Whole Life

    By Bradley Beylik

    7
  • Dishney

    Losing Your Head Over Disneyland

    By Vickie Chang

    8
  • Main

    Fetching the 10 Most Popular Dog Names

    By Vickie Chang

    9
  • Wax On, Wax Off

    Starting the New Year Recovering From Partying in Mammoth

    By Bradley Beylik

    10
  • A Clockwork Orange

    This Dreamboat Cleans Ladies' Houses for Free (Sans the Wrap)

    By Matt Coker

    11
  • Ex Cathedra

    Heckuva Job, Brownie! Top 5 Diocese of Orange Transgressions

    By Gustavo Arellano

    12
  • Crime & Sex

    Tiny Perv Says Teens' Blow Jobs Made Him Lucky at Casino

    By R. Scott Moxley

    13
  • Gay Marriage

    Rick Warren Reaps the Anti-Gay Pastors He's Sown in Uganda

    By Gustavo Arellano

    14
  • A Clockwork Orange

    She's Now a Wanted Real Housewife of Orange County

    By Matt Coker

    15
 
241 Toll Road

Why The Toll Road Is Dead

By Alex Brant-Zawadzki, Sunday, Feb. 10 2008 @ 8:16PM
Comments (7)
Categories:

The Foothill-South (241) toll road extension, as we know it, is dead.

Bold claim, you say? Presumptuous, maybe? Not so.

Recently, mi hermano Gustavo Arellano pinpointed the root cause of the Transportation Corridor Agencies' failure to gain Coastal Commission approval for their Final Solution to San Onofre State Beach: ARROGANCE. The TCA presumptuously and sometimes even indignantly refuted the majority of criticism of their project, as reflected in the Response to Comments section of the Environmental Impact Report. A juicy excerpt:

Comment Number: O19-13

Commenter: Terrell Watt Planning Consultants

Comment: There is a remarkable claim made that PM10 emissions will increase but that PM10 levels will not and that violations of state standards will not worsen (AQR 4-69, 4-70, 5-10). This defies all logic. And of course that is without accounting for most of the PM10 emissions. Obviously any increase in emissions will increase PM10 levels. The large emissions increases that would actually occur would increase the levels substantially, quite possibly above the federal standards.

Response: The comment is incorrect in summarizing the statements in the Draft EIS/SEIR...."

The comment is incorrect. The impacts are insignificant. You're wrong. We're not listening. Nya nya nya. This has been the general tone of the TCA's response to criticism in the past, and it continues today.

The TCA has appealed the Coastal Commission's decision to the U.S. Secretary of Commerce. According to the Coastal Zone Management Act, if a state denies approval of a project, the project builders can file an appeal with the Secretary of Commerce. It takes 265 days to analyze, or up to 325 days if extensions come into play.

Lance MacLean, who chairs the Foothill/Eastern TCA, told the LA Times, "Of the 16 miles to complete the toll road, only 2.2 miles are in the coastal zone. We can change the route, but that's just an idea, and of course, we will have to do studies."

What MacLean fails to understand, even though it was clearly articulated many times at the Feb. 6 Coastal Commission hearing which he attended, is that it doesn't matter how much of the project is in the coastal zone. If the project's impacts reach the coastal zone, then the Coastal Act applies.

Section 307(c)(3) of the Coastal Zone Management Act provides:

(3) (A) After final approval by the Secretary of a state's management program, any applicant for a required Federal license or permit to conduct an activity, in or outside of the coastal zone, affecting any land or water use or natural resource of the coastal zone of that state shall provide in the application to the licensing or permitting agency a certification that the proposed activity complies with the enforceable policies of the state's approved program and that such activity will be conducted in a manner consistent with the program. … No license or permit shall be granted by the Federal agency until the state or its designated agency has concurred with the applicant's certification or until, by the state's failure to act, the concurrence is conclusively presumed, unless the Secretary, on his own initiative or upon appeal by the applicant, finds, after providing a reasonable opportunity for detailed comments from the Federal agency involved and from the state, that the activity is consistent with the objectives of this title or is otherwise necessary in the interest of national security.


Even IF the TCA gets an override from the Secretary of Commerce, they will still have to come back to the Coastal Commission for a Coastal Development Permit for the project, according to Coastal Commissioner Steve Blank. "Given an 8-2 rejection by this commission," Blank told The Weekly, " they would have to either a) change the law that requires them to get a Coastal Development Permit, or b) change the makeup of the Coastal Commission so they can get an approval. Neither are impossible when a billion dollars are at stake."

Tags:

241, coastal commission, Environmental Impact Report, foothill south, Foothill/Eastern, Lance MacLean, Secretary of Commerce, steve blank, Terrell Watt, toll road
Comments (7) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • Mission Viejo's MacLean Recalled, Replaced by Anti-Recall Candidate [UPDATE: Yes, He Is... by 19 Votes] February 3, 2010
  • Letters from OC Weekly Readers January 28, 2010
  • Why Is Mission Viejo Mayor Lance MacLean Feeling Better About Election Day? January 14, 2010
  • Mission Viejo Council Candidate Makes it Official November 17, 2009
  • Local Republicans Back Recall of Mission Viejo's Lance MacLean... Again October 19, 2009

More About:

  • Lance MacLean
  • Coastal Zone Management Act
  • Gustavo Arellano
  • Trade Policy
  • Trade

Comments (7)

Pete van Nuys says:

 Indeed, arrogance did doom the 241-- arrogance of the OC Republican Party, the Building Industry Association which depends on the party to carry its water, elected losers like Bates, Walters, Campbell, Norby, who on this issue are most certainly "losers," and the sycophant losers on city councils throughout south county.
 How could TCA lose? They sit around regularly and congratulate each other on their brilliance and ability to shuck, jive, obfuscate, and hustle. Aren't they always right? Can't they change reality merely by denying it?
Guess what: Coastal Commissioners got your number. 20 years and a 3 foot pile of crap doesn't add up to research or mitigation-- it adds up to crap.
 "Biased?" Absolutely. The Coastal Commission is biased by their job, defending the coast. Did the Commission pop up over night, a sudden obnoxious challenge to TCA's shining plans? No, it's been there all along, a known, understood, and predictable obstacle to 241's grimy destruction.
 Wall Street must be lovin' the TCA now. Blowing $-millions on bogus science sure to be picked apart by a persnickety commission. Wagging it's finger at the commissioners and niggling over was is and isn't their jurisdiction. Behaving like the arrogant boneheads they are. And the best part: TCA's learned absolutely nothing in the process.

Posted On: Monday, Feb. 11 2008 @ 9:19AM
GREED & ARROGANCE says:

Arrogance and greed combined will defeat TCA's public and private investment and business objectives.....

Posted On: Monday, Feb. 11 2008 @ 12:48PM
"Reporter" (AKA Hack) Hater says:

Why didn't you print the entire response? Because it undermines your premise? Good thing the OC Weekly prints the whole truth. And by whole I mean 7.4% based on word count. But hey, what's 92.6% between friends.

I guess that's what one should expect from a publication that is picked up more for its escort service and phone sex ads than its reporting. Perhaps you should start working in the advertising department.

For the record here is the remainder of the response.

"... On page 5-10 (Table 5-3), the changes in regional PM10 emissions are shown for various FEC Alternatives and various growth Alternatives. The changes in PM10 emissions compared to the corresponding No Action Alternative range from an increase of five pounds per day to a decrease of five pounds per day. An increase or decrease of five pounds per day is not considered a significant change. As a comparison, the SCAQMD uses a very low operational significance threshold of 150 pounds of PM10 emissions per day. Theclaim that PM10 levels (concentrations) will not increase significantly at intersections is consistent with the regional forecast in the Draft EIS/SEIR which showed that the total PM10 emissions with and without the project does not change significantly. It is also consistent with the traffic assessment that shows the corridor Alternatives removing traffic from arterial roads and intersections, thereby reducing congestion at those intersections."

Now go back to law school and be a crappy lawyer rather than a crappy reporter. You'll be much less obvious as a crappy lawyer.

I love your linked in summary :

"I desire to help reveal, clarify and transmit information with the goal of helping others to make better, more informed decisions so that we all might have an easier time working together to try and foster progress."

and by love I mean it made me throw up in my mouth a bit.

You need modify it to read

"I desire to help reveal, clarify and transmit 7.5% of real information with the goal of helping others to make biased, less informed decisions so that we all might have an easier time by making the world the way I think it should be."

Posted On: Wednesday, Feb. 20 2008 @ 1:11PM
Alex Brant-Zawadzki says:

Hater:

Well? Which is it? 7.4% or 7.5%? Make up your mind! You TCA supporters can never get your numbers right.

I note you don't explain what about the remainder of the response undermined my premise.

By the way, kudos - I've never seen such a spiteful piece of apparently-researched bitchery actually be CROSS-POSTED before. The irony is, by visiting my personal blog, you've doubled my daily hit-count and brought me joy.

"Haters, if you need someone to hate on, feel free to hate on me." -Kat Williams

Posted On: Wednesday, Feb. 20 2008 @ 6:31PM
Jay says:

Listen, Alex, here's some advice from one journalist to another: when you quote something, you had better not just quote the relevant parts. A responsible journalist would quote the original statement in its entirety. When I get done with my 2,100 page review of War and Peace, I'll forward it to you as an example, so you never make this grievous mistake again.

Posted On: Thursday, Feb. 21 2008 @ 11:46AM
Juaneño Truth says:

David Belardes, Discovered to be a Non-Indian, Misrepresents Juaneño Tribe in Initial Agreement with TCA to Support Proposed Toll Road

TCA, the Transportation Corridor Agency, is currently in discussions with David Belardes, as a “representative” of the Juaneño Tribe, to drop opposition to the agency’s proposed toll road in exchange for a reported $350,000. But, it turns out that David Belardes is not a Native Juaneño or even Indian and is not an enrolled member of the Juaneño Tribe. Belardes’ Non-Indian ancestry was reported by the U.S. Department of the Interior, Office of Federal Acknowledgement during the Tribe’s ongoing petition for federal recognition. Domingo Yorba, Belardes’ paternal great grandfather whom he based his ancestral claims on, was classified as a Non-Indian in the Department’s report, which is part of the public record (JBMI 84A Proposed Findings, U.S. Department of the Interior, 2007, pp. 247-252.). The genealogical and historical evidence demonstrates that both paternal great grandparents of David Belardes were in fact of Mexican and Spanish descent—not Juaneño or California Indian.

As many Southern California residents know, in February 2008, the California Coastal Commission denied a proposal by the Transportation Corridor Agency (TCA) to extend the Foothill-South Toll Road through southern Orange County. Members of the Juaneño Tribe and other residents expressed concern that the proposed toll road could disturb sacred Juaneño ancestral sites. The TCA has since discussed a potential agreement for support of the proposed toll road with David Belardes, a San Juan Capistrano resident who falsely claims to represent the Juaneño Tribe.

Posted On: Monday, Sep. 15 2008 @ 8:57AM
Real Juaneno says:

David Belardes Found to be a Non-Indian and Misrepresented Juaneño Tribe in Agreement with TCA to Support Proposed Toll Road

Back in June, TCA paid David Belardes $350,000 in exchange for dropping opposition to the proposed toll road as a “representative” of the Juaneño Tribe—but David Belardes is not even Indian, let alone Native Juaneño. TCA, a state agency, is entering into an agreement with a man who is not who he says he is. The Office of Federal Acknowledgement, who is in charge of approving Tribes’ petition for federal recognition, reported that Belardes is not an Indian in their review of the Juaneño Tribe’s current petition. In his application, Belardes’ claim to Juaneño blood was based on his paternal great grandfather, Domingo Yorba. But the Office of Federal Acknowledgement later classified Domingo Yorba as a Non-Indian in its on-the-record report, found here: JBMI 84A Proposed Findings, U.S. Department of the Interior, 2007, pp. 247-252. In fact, public genealogical and historical records show that both of Belardes’ paternal great grandparents were actually of Mexican and Spanish descent, not Juaneño or California Indian. Belardes is misrepresenting the Tribe’a position on the toll road, a road that could potentially disrupt sacred Juaneño ancestral sites.


Posted On: Tuesday, Oct. 7 2008 @ 1:50PM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search Navel Gazing


Follow

Email tips to tips@ocweekly.com

SlideShows»

  • TRMRS, Cosmonauts, Lights Rays @ TrashPretty
  • Date a Derby Dame!
  • VANS Costa Mesa Grand Opening: Christian Hosoi, Jeff Grosso, Omar Hassan and More
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Racist OC Register Fustercluck of the Day
  • Orange County Boasts 3 of the Top 10 Coolest Beach Houses For Sale
  • Mother of Four Accused of Killing Baby Daughter, Fracturing Skull of Twin Boy
  • Ousted MV Mayor Wants Recount, Considers Suing City, DA and RoV
  • Playing Pool at Pub a Contact Sport
  • More Recent Entries...
  • The Liberal OC Sues Orange Juice! in Media Pissing Match of the Decade (25)
  • Miguel Pulido's Only Friend--Adam Probolsky, GOP Legend! (20)
  • [UPDATED:] Bessie Whyman, O.C. Homicide No. 3: 84-Year-Old Robbed, Tortured and Murdered (17)
  • Crystal Cathedral Schuller Clan Used as Prime Example of Why Pastors Shouldn't Hire Family (15)
  • The Curious Case of Anaheim's Founding, Probably Mythological Goat (13)
  • It's Not the 7-Year Itch, It's Your Toilet Seat!
  • Dishney: Flickr Set Documents "Fat People in Disneyland"
  • Girls Volleyball Coach Could Get a Year for Allegedly Exposing Player's Vagina and Breasts
  • Dishney: Woman Groped While Riding the Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
  • Have You Seen Jesse James' Pit Bull Cinnabon?
  • Tue
    9
  • Wed
    10
  • Thu
    11
  • Fri
    12
  • Sat
    13
  • Sun
    14
  • Mon
    15
This week's best events
3 Best Things To Do on Tuesday, Feb 9
  • Akram Khan Dance Company: Bahok

    Where: Irvine Barclay Theatre

    Type: Dance, Performing Arts, Theater

  • Thao With the Get Down Stay Down; Thermals

    Where: Detroit Bar

    Type: Indie, Rock

  • Venus Infers; Matt Kolar and the Angry Mob; Brown and Blue

    Where: The Prospector

    Type: Alternative, Indie, Rock

  • submit an event
  • 43 more things to do today >>

Twitter Feed

Follow Navel Gazing on Twitter

More Twitter >>

Navel Gazing on Digg

Links

About Us | Work for OC Weekly | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Village Voice Media All rights reserved.