Robert Douglas Fischer Murder Case Dismissed by Arizona Judge (as Expected): Update

See the update on the Arizona judge, as expected, dismissing the murder case against Robert Douglas Fischer of San Clemente.

ORIGINAL POST, MARCH 7, 11:41 A.M.: A judge in Arizona has ordered the release from jail of a San Clemente man who in December was convicted of murdering his stepdaughter's husband.

Prosecutors in Phoenix have also requested a dismissal of the case against Robert Douglas Fischer.

But the 54-year-old divorce lawyer, who has an office in Tustin, is not out of desert-hot water just yet.

Robert Douglas Fischer, Tustin Lawyer Convicted of Murder, on Dateline

A dismissal would be a procedural move that would allow prosecutors to appeal Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Karen Mullins' Feb. 28 decision to grant Fischer a new trial because, she ruled, no evidence was presented that he pulled the trigger on the gun that killed 49-year-old Norman "Lee" Radder.

Dwane Cates, an attorney for Fischer, told the Associated Press he expects his client will be released from jail by early Saturday.

"I was obviously very excited," Cates said of the judge's ruling on the jury's verdict. "I believe the judge was correct."

Thumbnail image for norman-lee-radder_faceb.jpg
Lee Radder, R.I.P.
But Maricopa County Attorney's Office spokesman Jerry Cobb warned, "We intend to continue to pursue this case."

Fischer was in town for a visit to the Radder family home in Queen Creek, southeast of Phoenix, on Dec. 30, 2010. After an evening of drinking, former Irvine entrepreneur and dirt bike magazine publisher Radder died of a single shot through his right eye from Fischer's .38 handgun.

Prosecutors allege Fischer staged the shooting to appear to be a suicide and early in the case pointed to inconsistencies in what he is claimed to have told the dispatcher and Maricopa County sheriff's investigators about what happened.

But Mullins found reasonable doubt existed because DNA evidence showed Radder handled the gun and magazine and physical evidence did not support the contention of a homicide detective that Fischer moved the body to make it appear to be the scene of a suicide.

UPDATE, MARCH 11, 1:40 P.M.: As expected, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Karen Mullins on Monday dismissed the murder case against Robert Douglas Fischer of San Clemente.

The judge also re-affirmed Fischer must be released from custody.

As detailed in the original post, prosecutors sought the dismissal as a procedural move so they can appeal Mullins having overturned a jury's verdict that Fischer is guilty of murder.

Email: mcoker@ocweekly.com. Twitter: @MatthewTCoker. Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook!



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
5 comments
tk827
tk827

I can't believe the conviction didn't stand on this. Suicide... Really?

camesq
camesq

Judge Mullins should be commended for her excellent ruling.  The wheels of justice are finally moving in the right direction for Rob.

jscesq
jscesq

In ruling on the motion for new trial the Trial Judge spends 31 pages analyzing the evidence and explaining why, based on the physical evidence, Lee Radder committed suicide and Mr. Fischer could not have done what the State claimed. She also spends a great deal of time detailing the incompetence of the investigating officer, Detective Acosta. 


The ruling is available on the Maricopa County court website.  


www.courtminutes.maricopa.gov/docs/Criminal/032014/m6194627.pdf 

949girl
949girl topcommenter

I think I saw this case on Dateline or 48 Hours. 

MatthewTCoker
MatthewTCoker topcommenter

@949girl It was Dateline; I missed it but there is a link to the preview above.

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Fashion

General

Loading...