Is AG Kamala Harris the Wicked Witch of Western Abortions in Hoag's Pact with St. Joe's?

An anti-abortion news site is reporting (and a Catholic news site is picking up) an allegation that California Attorney General Kamala D. Harris may either stop the recent partnership between a Catholic healthcare provider and Hoag Hospital or force the Newport Beach medical center to perform abortions. Those fears are based on a mainstream media report indicating the Attorney General's office is investigating possible lies by Hoag's CEO regarding abortions when Harris signed off on the partnership with St. Joseph's Health System.

Harris approved the formation of Covenant Health Network after Hoag CEO Robert Braithwaite famously maintained his decision to prohibit abortions at the Newport Beach hospital had nothing to do with the new partnership with St. Joe's. Instead, Braithwaite claimed, abortions were being banned because so few were performed at Hoag annually, leading to what he characterized as increased chances of botched procedures.

Robert Braithwaite, Hoag CEO, Lays Blame for Banning Abortions on Hospital's Incompetence

His decision was not welcomed by many of Braithwaite's own physicians, especially after St. Joseph's officials confessed continued abortions at Hoag were "non-negotiable" in the partnership negotiations.

Hoag Hospital Abortion Ban Draws Protesters

Robert Braithwaite
Since then, Los Angeles Times columnist Michael Hiltzik has written Harris' office, which "has the legal authority to rule on any change like an abortion ban as a condition of her approving a major transaction involving California nonprofit medical institutions," fears Braithwaite may have misrepresented Hoag's yearly abortion statistics. The CEO had said about 100 or fewer were performed annually.

Meanwhile, the Attorney General's office is also reportedly investigating allegations that Hoag has not fulfilled its conditions for allowing the abortion ban, including ensuring that women, especially low-income women, still have access to abortions in Hoag's coverage area.

Those two investigatory threads, reports anti-abortion Life Site News, could lead Harris to squash the partnership or impose mandatory abortions at Hoag.

"AG Harris has a 100% score from NARAL Pro-choice America," reports Life Site News.

Just above the "Click to Donate" button.

Email: Twitter: @MatthewTCoker. Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook!

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Andrew Cusumano
Andrew Cusumano

Oc weekly, why have you not mentioned the hawthorne canine shooting incident? I understand that's la county, but your locals want some information; they're pissed at the Hawthorne pd's handling of the situation, and the owner of the canine probably wants a widespread outlet for his inquiry and outrage. Either way, it's probably going to benefit you.


So Braithwaite says Hoag regularly botches seldom performed surgeries? Or only abortions? Either way, his argument engender much patient confidence.

MatthewTCoker topcommenter

@Andrew Cusumano It's in our Calendar section in the Out of County Experiences category.

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault