Irma Jacobo Navarro Is 'a Good, Caring Mom' Despite Shackling Her 10 y.o. Son: Police

Categories: Crime-iny

Click here for update on the charges being dropped against the mother.

Last week, it was a Santa Ana mom accused of starving one of her nine children, a 4-year-old girl who weighs 18 pounds.

Now it's a Santa Ana mom who allegedly kept one of her three children chained and locked inside their apartment while she went off to work.

But at least Irma Navarro apparently left her 10-year-old son food and video games.

Antonia Benitez, Mother of 9, Accused of Starving 4-y.o. Daughter That Weighs 18 Lbs.

Still, the boy has been taken into protective custody, and his 37-year-old mama faces charges of willful cruelty to a child, according to authorities.

An older sibling was at school and a younger one with a babysitter when the 10-year-old was seen by neighbors hopping around on one leg outside the apartment unit just before noon Thursday, according to Corporal Anthony Bertagna, the Santa Ana Police Department spokesman.

When a neighborhood mom asked the boy what he was doing, he is said to have replied he was heading to a friend's house to be freed from his chains. He was later seen crying next to a tree, where a man had him wait as he went off to get bolt cutters. That's about when police arrived.

Navarro allegedly told officers she could not afford a babysitter for two children, but she was worried the 10-year-old would get into trouble were he not shackled while she was away, especially fearful of the gang activity in her neighborhood.

UPDATE, JULY 22, 2:18 P.M.: Irma Jacobo Navarro, who is being held without bail, was due to be arraigned sometime today on one felony and one misdemeanor count each of child abuse and endangerment.

A janitor and single mother, the 37-year-old is, "by all accounts . . . a good, caring mom," Santa Ana Police Corporal Anthony Bertagna reportedly told City News Service, while also describing the 10-year-old boy as a "problem child" with a habit of leaving home and not returning until 9 or 9:30 p.m.

The boy "cusses at her, doesn't listen to her, so she's at her wit's end," Bertagna said of the mother. "She's a good mom. The house is clean; the kids are well-spoken and
well-behaved. But apparently the 10-year-old is becoming a problem child when she goes to work."

Bertagna understood her motives, but mentioned, "unfortunately, as sympathetic as we are to a discipline problem, the answer is not to commit a criminal act." Being padlocked to a 6-foot-long aluminum chain wrapped four or five times around one's ankles, as the child was, could have ended in tragedy had there been, say, an apartment fire, the police spokesman noted.

The boy has joined his other siblings in protective custody, police said.

Email: Twitter: @MatthewTCoker. Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook!

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
949girl topcommenter

I'm on the mom's side in this case.  You read daily about Santa Ana gang members dying or being sent away for life.  Sounds like the mom was desperate after reading the update about him being a problem child.  If you have ever gone down to the central jail and seen the people visiting they all seem to be visiting someone that is in a gang.  I don't think she went about it in the best way but I'm just not getting an "abusive vibe" in this case.  I felt the need to comment again.  A lot of people would say "I'd do anything to keep my kid out of a gang even if it meant chaining them up" and I think she is one of those people.  Just my thoughts.


If it's going to keep the brat out of a gang, then chain the little darling up! I'm on mom's side.

949girl topcommenter

Not defending the mom AT ALL but I can see her logic as to chaining him so he's not exposed to gang activity which sounds terrible on my part for even defending her because I think what she did is awful but it would almost be better to keep someone locked inside as to avoid exposing them to gangs if they are rampant in the neighborhood.  Because once you get busted in a gang related crime it's almost certain you'll spend the rest of your life behind bars.  I don't know, couldn't she have found him some sort of free community program?  Aside from this incident was she abusive? 

Robert Saenz
Robert Saenz

interesting . . . a report about another brown lady. though, i wonder whats going on - in orange county . . . isn't that where you are?

MatthewTCoker topcommenter

@Robert Saenz Who's on first ...

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault