OC's Tollroad Agency Loses Federal Lawsuit Against Commerce Department

Categories: Court
TCA toll liars.jpg
Please stop: Wall Street wants all your change
In its determination to satisfy the continual demands of Wall Street investment houses for more profits, Orange County's Transportation Corridor Agency (TCA) wants to go billions of dollars further in bond debt by building a 16-mile tollroad linking state route 241 with Interstate 5.

But in 2008 the California Coastal Commission rejected the plan and the TCA appealed that decision to the U.S. Secretary of Commerce, who ultimately also determined the proposed road violated the California Coastal Act.

The following year TCA lawyer Robert D. Thornton filed a federal Freedom of Information Act with the Commerce Department for records pertaining to the unfavorable ruling and were given access only to seven full documents out of 281. 

The TCA filed a lawsuit claiming the federal agency improperly withheld records.

This week inside the Ronald Reagan Federal Courthouse in Santa Ana, U.S. District Court Judge Josephine Staton Tucker formally handed the TCA another defeat.

In a 10-page ruling, Tucker declared that the TCA is not entitled to the withheld records because they were properly exempted from disclosure by federal law as part of the internal "deliberative process" used by the Commerce secretary.

TCA toll liars 241.jpg
Toll jam
In 1996, the TCA laughably hailed its San Joaquin Hills Transportation Corridor as the world's model for transportation projects. Within a year it became obvious that the agency's usage projections were worthless, deceitful numbers concocted only to sell bonds and make billions of dollars of profit for powerful Wall Street investment houses. That road is now a debt-ridden financial nightmare that will cost more than $12 billion more than originally claimed.

Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
vegandawg23 topcommenter

Have you people driven on the freeways lately. More roads, toll or not, profit or non is a no-brainer. 


Yes, build more freeways, so we can build more houses, so more people can move in, so we have to build more freeways...

Start tearing lanes out and replacing them with trains. If it keeps going we'll be worse than Houston.


@vegandawg23Drive them every day. There's  nothing wrong with the freeways. Besides we pay enough in taxes to make more freeways. The money is being misused by government. If you want to pay more money to a corrupt government, just mail it to them.


@BobLoblawsLawBlog ? People gonna move here whether more houses are built or not. Supply and command how does it work? It's a matter of whether you want to sit in traffic for 3 hours or 2 hours. Whether you want to pay 500k for a house in the barrio or 150k. And lol at trains. Like I want to ride with a bunch of people speaking spanish and a bunch of weirdos walking down the aisles asking for money. Just build more roads. What's wrong with you anyways?!? This is really simple and you're making it complicated. Not surprised you're a lawyer. 

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault