After Flip Flops, California Judges Decide if a Balcony is Part of a Residence

california burglary definition balcony.jpg
Where is Albert when you need him?
Around midnight on Aug. 5, 2009 in Los Angeles, Jammal Haneef Yarbrough climbed nine feet to a second story residential balcony containing two bicycles and was clinging to a four-foot high steel railing when a dog in the home began barking and the resident emerged to confront him.

Yarbrough fled and, though he didn't take anything, was arrested. After Superior Court Judge Ronald S. Coen declared the balcony part of the residence, a jury convicted the defendant of burglary.

The defendant appealed his case to a California Court of Appeal based in Los Angeles and got his conviction reversed.

In a six-page, March 2011 opinion written by Justice Robert M. Mallano--a former LA prosecutor and superior court judge, the appellate court decided that the second-floor balcony was not an enclosed area of the residence and therefore by definition a burglary couldn't have occurred.

Mallano felt so sure of his stance that he published his opinion for official use in future cases.

But thankfully last week the California Supreme Court applied common sense and reversed the reversal. 

"Whenever a private, residential apartment and its balcony are on the second or a higher floor of a building, and the balcony is designed to be entered only from inside the apartment (thus extending the apartment's living space), the balcony is part of the apartment," Justice Joyce L. Kennard wrote for the Supreme Court. "The railing of such a balcony marks the apartment's outer boundary, any slight crossing of which is an entry for purposes of the burglary statute."

Yarbrough, 26, remains locked up inside the California Medical Facility, a medical/psychiatric prison in Vacaville.

Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook!
My Voice Nation Help
5 comments
DonkeyHotay
DonkeyHotay topcommenter

The courts have also ruled that taking anything from the OPEN BED of a pickup truck is Vehicle Burglary.

 

 

JGlanton
JGlanton topcommenter

Interesting article. It leaves a big question open at the end: Why is bagged balcony burglar Jammal Haneef in the medical/psychiatric facility?

rscottmoxley1
rscottmoxley1

A related ground floor area would be called a patio--not a balcony.

clark_bennett
clark_bennett

Well Duh,  But I guess any thing left on a ground floor balcony or a balcony with exterior stairs isn't part of the residence and is fair game?  

LarryDuck
LarryDuck

 @clark_bennett 

 

Stated: "...any thing left on a ground floor balcony or a balcony with exterior stairs isn't part of the residence and is fair game? "

 

No... If one were to leave personal belongings on a patio on the ground floor and someone stole the belongings, under statute that would constitute theft, not burglary. Two different statutes under California law.

 

Theft differs from burglary in that the theft is a taking of property that DOES NOT involve person-to-person interaction. A person merely takes property that does not belong to him.

 

Burglary, in contrast to theft , is the entering of a building or residence with the intention to commit a theft or any felonious crime. Burglary does not require that property be stolen or that person-to-person interaction occur.

 

Robbery, in contrast to theft, is a taking of property that DOES involve person-to-person interaction with force, intimidation, and/or coercion.

 

Hope this helps you understand the law.

 

~LD~

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...