[UPDATED with Borja Denial:] Odon Borja, Who Killed Strawberry Picker Over Family Blood Feud, and Robert Lee Carney Jr., Who Murdered Teacher for $30, Seek Paroles Today

Categories: Crime-iny
Thumbnail image for simon-cowell-thumbs-down.jpg
UPDATE, OCT. 21, 1:16 P.M.: Parole was also denied today for Odon Borja, who is serving a 25 years to life sentence at Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego for the 1986 murder of a strawberry picker in a Cypress field over a family blood feud.

Borja, 56, is next eligible for a parole hearing in 2014.

The board denied Borja's parole this morning because he still poses an unreasonable risk to public safety, according to an Orange County District Attorney's office statement.

Our previous update on Robert Lee Carney Jr. also being denied parole today failed to mention that the parole board meeting at Mule Creek State Prison in Ione cited two major rules violations--obstructing a police officer and battery on an inmate--within the past six months by the inmate. That shows Carney is not adequately rehabilitated and continues to pose a threat to society, the board ruled.

UPDATE, OCT. 21, 10:59 A.M.: Parole was denied today for Robert Lee Carney Jr., who is serving a life sentence at Mule Creek State Prison in Ione for the Dec. 16, 1975, murder of 55-year-old Anaheim High School teacher Gene Henderson.

Carney, 56, is next eligible for a parole hearing in 2016.

ORIGINAL POST, OCT. 21, 8:29 A.M.: Orange County deputy district attorneys are at opposite ends of the state this morning opposing the paroles of a man convicted of slaying a laborer in a Cypress strawberry field over a bloody family feud, and another killer put away for bludgeoning to death an Anaheim High School teacher for $30 (split three ways).

picking-strawberries-150.jpg
In the first case, Odon Borja had his originally scheduled July 25 parole hearing at Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego postponed due to a glitch with the recording equipment. It was re-set for this morning.

Deputy DA Heidi Garrel was originally going to appear before the board in July, but now her colleague Elisabeth McKinley gets the call. Edward Munoz is the former deputy DA who prosecuted the original murder case. See:


Three brothers of Borja and three of Gumaro Pineda got into a heated argument during a December 1983 festival in Acapulco, Mexico, before the Borja clan killed the members of the Pineda clan. A Pineda family friend who witnessed the murders was later killed, as was Borja's father--all within a week of the original slayings.

Three years later, then 30-year-old Odon Borja was drinking with his cousin Juan Cruz Torres in Orange County when the 22-year-old urged Borja to avenge his father's death by killing Gumaro Pineda, who was then working in a strawberry field in Cypress.

The cousins took two weapons, a .38 caliber pistol and a long barrel .22 caliber pistol, with nearly 100 rounds of ammunition and set out the morning of April 17, 1986, for the strawberry field at the southwest corner of Katella Avenue and Valley View Street. They parked on a dirt driveway and walked onto the field, where Torres pointed out 33-year-old Pineda.

Borja called out Pineda's name from less than 15 feet away. When Pineda rose to face him, Borja unloaded the .38 caliber pistol into him. As Pineda lay wounded, Borja walked closer and fired several more times, including the killshot. The cousins then scrammed for their vehicle, but not without first firing their guns into the air and at a crowd of more than 100 workers.

They tried to get away but were pursued by Cypress cops. The chase lasted for about five miles before the pair was caught and arrested. Besides a murder rap, Borja had been driving with a blood alcohol content of .14 percent, which is over the legal limit.

Cypress investigators learned from farm workers what prompted Pineda's slaying. Torres and Borja were convicted in December 1986 of first-degree murder. Borja was sentenced on Jan. 23, 1987, to 25 years to life in state prison.

As they were prepared to do in July, prosecutors will oppose now-56-year-old Borja's parole on grounds that he has displayed a lack of remorse, that he's undergone a lack of rehabilitation and that he possesses a capability to commit another violent crime.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
5 comments
mitch young
mitch young

I make it, by conservative calculation, at least $800,000 to incarcerate this guy. That's a pretty high price to pay for importing family feuds from Mexico in order to get some strawberries picked. Especially in a suburban environment where U-Pick could have worked well. Of course the grower didn't pay that tab, we all did.

20ftJesus
20ftJesus

I dunno.  30 bucks is 30 bucks.  Jus' don't get caught next time. 

Joe
Joe

And what was the cost for Carneys, intellectual act?

mitch young
mitch young

The difference, you see, is that Carney is likely a US citizen, probably son of US citizens and grandson of US citizens. Mexico is another country, with its own laws, its own customs. We don't need to import their trouble when we can generate our own. Cheap strawberries aren't worth it.

mitch young
mitch young

Carney foks, hate 'em, little hands.

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...