OC Legal Scholars Erwin Chemerinsky and John Eastman Pop Up in Florida Federal Judge's Ruling Declaring "Obamacare" Unconstitutional

Orange County's two most-quoted legal scholars turn up in the Florida federal judge's ruling Monday that found parts of "Obamacare" unconstitutional and declared the entire law must be made "null and void."

Specifically cited by U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson is Erwin Chemerinsky, the founding dean of UC Irvine's law school. The judge points to a statement Chemerinsky made in a video that also features his good friend and frequent philosophical sparring partner John Eastman, the former dean of Chapman University's law school. 

Eastman and Chemerinsky.jpg
Courtesy of Chapman University
Erwin Chemerinsky (left) and John Eastman engage in one of their frequent legal debates.
"I must reluctantly conclude that Congress exceeded the bounds of its authority in passing the act with the individual mandate," Vinson writes in reference to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and its mandate that individuals must purchase health insurance, a provision that is scheduled to kick in in 2014.

"The health-care market is more than one-sixth of the national economy, and without doubt, Congress has the power to reform and regulate this market," Vinson continues. "That has not been disputed in this case. The principal dispute has been about how Congress chose to exercise that power here."

To give an example of how Vinson believes the system is supposed to work, you must turn to page 47 of his ruling, on which he cites (and provides the link to) "Wheat, Weed, and ObamaCare: How the Commerce Clause Made Congress All-Powerful,"  a video Reason.TV posted on Aug. 25, 2010.

"For example," Vinson writes, "in the course of defending the Constitutionality of the individual mandate, and responding to the same concerns identified above, often-cited law professor and dean of the University of California Irvine School of Law Erwin Chemerinsky has opined that although 'what people choose to eat well might be regarded as a personal liberty' (and thus unregulable), 'Congress could use its commerce power to require people to buy cars.'"

Here is the video:

Watch, and you'll discover the producers pull off the impossible, making Eastman come off, well, reasonable and Chemerinsky totally crackers.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

It seems that from watching the video, the difference between Mr. Eastman and Mr. Chemerinsky is "Do we want to live in a nation of Limited Government?" This is an excellent resource for demonstrating the difference between liberals and conservatives.

Do we believe in having a Constitution? Mr Chemerinsky does not seem to believe that there are any limits on the power of the central government. Mr. Eastman seems to believe that we can read the simple language of the Constitution and apply it to Limiting the Power of the Central Government.

The authors of the Constitution obviously felt that Federalism was the primary way to protect our Liberty. The Federal Government has proven to be inept and inefficient at almost everything they set out to do. Being inept and inefficient is not cheap, either. Congress has spent all our tax revenue plus a deficit of $1.5 Trillion and... what did we get?? We are bankrupting our children for this??

I am all for slashing the federal government, balancing the budget and repaying the debt. It is disgraceful for adults to waste money and force our children to repay it.


Such right wing BS! They don't want the public option because they don't want private insurers to have competition from the government. So the compromise is to have this done through private insurers, but that's what they're finding unconsitutional? Shenanigans!

Soren Kay
Soren Kay

"Watch and you'll discover the producers pull off the impossible, making Eastman come off, well, reasonable, and Chemerinsky totally crackers."

O'Rly? Chemerinsky always sounds like he is completely full of shit.


Yes, really. Chemerinsky is a brilliant mind; Eastman, a kook only Chapman could love...

Now Trending

Anaheim Concert Tickets

From the Vault