[UPDATED:] Huntington Beach Company Uses 'Toons, Rappers and Twilight Stars to Lure Kids to its Prepaid Debit Cards
Newberry, who calls his company a pioneer in the teen pre-paid card market, chatted with me because he was miffed at my original blog post below. When an item starts, "Do you suppose a special place in Hell has been reserved for those behind Huntington Beach-based Plastic Cash International . . .," you can't really blame him.
Actually, he's also miffed at the original coverage that led to my post. A financial columnist in St. Louis called on Newberry because another company's credit card emblazoned with a photo of the Kardashians was kaput. The fees were outrageous and, as it turns out, the company had not been authorized to use teen America's favorite sisters.
The controversy, the columnist reasoned, had drawn attention to the youth pre-paid market. Hello, Brian "The Pioneer" Newberry. The thing is, Newberry told me, his Myplash cards are designed to help kids manage their money better. He does not gouge them with fees like the banks do. Actually, like the banks used to do. Nowadays, those under 21 need a parental co-signer to open checking accounts.
"Not all pre-paid cards are bad," Newberry said.
He gets where I was coming from: that credit cards are evil and wallet plastic geared toward kids seems to be leading them into the mouth of that evil. But another way of looking at it, the Newberry way of looking at it, is kids can only spend as much as they have pre-loaded onto their Myplash cards. Their parents can track their spending.
Besides monthly fees that are under five bucks, Myplash does charge small ATM fees. But a page on the Myplash website shows kids and their parents how to avoid them.
Newberry notes that as celebrities, rock stars and cartoon characters have been authorized to join the Myplash roster, he has not issued press releases. You don't see Myplash commercials on Nickelodeon. He's kept things relatively low-key. Plastic Cash International only has 30 employees, he said. Newberry wants to make money, sure, but not on the backs of the young.
He swears this and, I must say, he makes a compelling case.
Original Post, December 14, 7:38 a.m.: Do you suppose a special place in Hell has been reserved for those behind Huntington Beach-based Plastic Cash International, which just unveiled a new line of prepaid debit cards for children?
You can't miss them: they are the cards that feature images of Bratz, rappers, rockers, surfers, Twilight stars--and the ubiquitous MasterCard logo.
As columnist Matthew Hathaway writes for St. Louis Today, the cards marketed for teens as young as 13 have raised eyebrows.
He quotes Bill Hardekopf, author of The Credit Card Guidebook, saying while there's nothing illegal about youth-marketed debit cards, "it sure bothers me as a parent and seems to cross over the line of what is good taste."
But founder and president Brian Newberry described Plastic Cash as a socially conscious company out to help young consumers and their parents. It's not, he said, about "gouging teens."
Hathaway concedes Myplash fees are low when compared to many other
prepaid cards, and Newberry claims his 10-year-old company goes out of its way to tell cardholders how to avoid many
of those fees.
But Hardekopf says in the column young consumers would be better off steering clear of most youth-marketed cards and getting a debit card the old-fashioned way, by opening a traditional checking account. Besides the fees being lower, checking accounts help build and improve credit scores.
While Newberry acknowledges teens can't build a credit history by
using his cards, he points out they can't ruin one either.
Still, why even go down the plastic road if you can avoid it?