With the smell of spring training fresh in the air around the old ballpark, it's been the best of times and the worst of times for
Matt McCarthy. The
30-year-old 28-year-old medical intern at Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center in New York City has seen
Odd Man Out, his recently published book based on his minor league pitching career in the Angels organization, excerpted in
Sports Illustrated, hailed as the farm-league equivilent to
Jim Bouton's polo groundbreaking major-league tell-all
Ball Four and compared quite favorably to
Bull Durham, which--who knows?--could mean a movie deal will one day be in the offing.
But fans, former teammates and the
Orange County Register are lashing out at McCarthy, a hard-throwing lefty who the Angels drafted out of Yale in the
26th 21st round of the 2002 Major League Baseball draft, which was held during the height of what has become known as the Steroid Era and the same summer Anaheim won the World Series. Halo diehards are miffed McCarthy did not give a heads up to former teammates he wrote about before the salacious excerpt-and now book-was published. A coach's interactions with players should remain confidential, like confessions to a priest or revelations to a therapist, others have honked.
Former player
Heath Miller Luther had not read the book but, based on what he'd heard, complained "99.9 percent is not true. The .1 percent that is true is the fact that most of the American players don't speak Spanish, and most of the Hispanics don't speak English." That was part of a
long comment he left on the online version of the
Reg story, where
Sam Miller writes, "it's a book that, if we're honest about it, makes . . . the Angels look bad." Many within the organization told Miller they knew nothing of the many incidents McCarthy detailed that showed oversized boys will be boys.
I must make two confessions: I'm an Angel fan, and I loved the book. For a physician and washout pitcher, McCarthy has one hell of an ear for fascinating stories--or, if his Halo critics are correct, quite the wild imagination. He's got a pretty decent writer's touch, too.
More >>